Counterpoint: Merit Prevails

A Rebuttal Against Abigail Hollie-Stern

By: Roland McNamara, June 30, 2023

Insomniac-Scholars Fend Off Sleep While Designing Airplanes

Today, the Supreme Court struck down some key provisions of affirmative action. MEDIAPRESENCE’s own Abigail Hollie-Stern discusses her views on the decision and its future implications in this piece.

One of my favorite duties as a member of the press is offering rebuttals to my fellow journalists about their cockamamie ideas of society – that and sculpting the thoughts of the masses into my own terra cotta army. Here’s a brief counterpoint to my friend and colleague, on why today’s news will be a positive influence on American life.

In striking down Grutter vs. Bollinger and Roe vs. Wade, the Supreme Court has signaled its activist outlook. While I’m always wary of giving the court too much power or authority over the other two branches of our government, I do find judicial overreach less disturbing when it’s ideologically aligned with my interests. Luckily, this is such a scenario.

A reform of affirmative action means a return to the idea of meritocracy, a dirty word in liberal spaces and a dying ideal across even conservative America. Students who want to learn, who study hard, and who are keenly aware of their college prospects early in life, will now have less competition to enter top-tier universities. With greater meritocracy will come greater responsibility, mostly on parents to teach their children at young ages about the importance of grades, hard work, and sociability.

Before the decision today, a student who coasted through school, received less than stellar grades, but happened to be the right race or background had a leg-up on those students who studied diligently every day, partook in afterschool activities like polo and the foxhunt, and sacrificed their sense of identity and self-esteem to the alter of future success.

The increased chances of landing a spot at an Ivy league school for these students is nothing short of life-changing; there are so few spots after tallying the donations and counting the legacy applicants, and those who don’t make it see themselves as failures. After college rejection, many promising minds end up in the military or on the noose-end of a rope, apprenticing under salty seafarers.

Hollie-Stern laments the end of black excellence; while it’s true that the end of affirmative action will mean a reduction in black acceptances (as its practice saw the figure rise) I regret to inform many a young suburban boy that this new legal paradigm will see a new shift in higher education acceptance rates – the rise of the Asian.

Hyper-intelligent, unwaveringly focused, iron-willed, and born into a culture of expected excellence, campus Asian populations will balloon to figures only dreamt of until today. The lack of violence or exploitation across Asia through the last two millennia was an unfortunate mark against their people during the admissions process, but that process changed today.

While some elements of individual background will still be taken into account, the creeping specter of merit will soon lead to a yellow uprising, in which Chinese, Japanese, and Korean elite will work in the shared harmony of their culture, controlling our public institutions and shaping the West into a new global Orient.

I predict that their merciless efficiency will overwork and under-nourish the general populace, and that Americans will emigrate en masse to the wild Canadian wilderness, to be free and live as our forefathers did. What a paradise it will be.

In summary, overturning Grutter vs. Bollinger will increase the value of meritocracy, prevent many of the nation’s best and brightest from becoming sailors, free up those precious few non-legacy Ivy League slots, embolden Asian Americans to overtake our public infrastructure, and make no noticeable impact on those with vested stock options. A significant event in American history, but rather minor if everybody suddenly dies.

Previous
Previous

California Dreamers and “Art for Art’s Sake”

Next
Next

The Door to Black Education Has Just Been Locked